If your crypto tax report shows a gain that doesn’t look right, start with the transactions behind it. A missing wallet, an old exchange account or a transfer labelled as a sale can change the result considerably.
There are three situations worth separating: a mistake in your records, crypto you can no longer recover, and a tax return that has already been lodged with incorrect figures. Each needs a different approach.
When the software has an incomplete picture
Crypto tax software can help organise years of activity, but it still needs a complete history. Before relying on a report, check every exchange and wallet you have used, including accounts you no longer trade through.
Missing purchase history
A ‘missing cost basis’ warning often means the software can see coins arriving but cannot find how you acquired them. Check older imports and transfers before accepting a zero purchase cost.
Transfers showing as sales
Moving crypto between wallets you own can appear as a disposal if only one side was imported. Find the matching transaction and check that the software recognises the movement as an internal transfer. Review any network fees separately.
The same transaction appearing twice
Overlapping CSV imports and API connections can duplicate trades. Compare transaction IDs and import dates before deleting anything, and keep a copy of the original records.
Rewards recorded as ordinary deposits
Staking rewards, airdrops and DeFi transactions need a closer look. A generic deposit label may leave the report incomplete. Check what actually happened before changing the transaction type.
Fees that do not look right
Review gas and network fees alongside the related transaction. Their treatment depends on what the fee relates to, so avoid applying the same adjustment to every fee.
Once you have corrected the imports, compare the balances at the report date with the balances in your wallets and exchanges at that same date. If they differ, keep investigating before you lodge.
When crypto has been lost or stolen
Losing access to crypto is different from a software warning. Keep the wallet address, transaction history, purchase records and evidence linking the wallet to you. Record what happened and when, while the details are still available.
A capital loss may be available where the relevant requirements are met and you can establish ownership and permanent loss. Compensation can affect the amount. A frozen withdrawal or an exchange entering administration needs its own assessment because recovery may still be possible.
If a scam or theft was involved, preserve messages, transaction IDs and any reports you have made. Ask your tax agent to review the evidence and the appropriate income year before claiming a loss.
If you have already lodged the return
You may discover a missing wallet after lodging, or receive an ATO message asking you to check your crypto reporting. Read the message carefully and check its deadline. Work back through the records before making changes to the return.
- Bring together the complete wallet and exchange history for each affected year.
- Correct missing transactions, duplicates and transfer labels.
- Recalculate the gains, losses and income using the corrected records.
- Ask your tax agent which returns need an amendment and keep the supporting reports.
Individuals generally have two years to request an amendment, starting the day after the notice of assessment is sent. Other circumstances can change the available process, so check the deadline for your own return.
Getting your records ready for a review
You do not need to tidy everything before asking for help. Start with the software report, any warnings you can see, and a list of your wallets and exchanges. That gives us somewhere practical to begin.
Forward Accounting can help reconcile crypto records, review the evidence for lost or stolen assets, and work through corrections to earlier returns. Bring your ATO correspondence too if you have received any.
General information only, current as of November 2026. The treatment of a transaction or loss depends on your circumstances. Speak with a registered tax agent before acting.
Related Service
Cryptocurrency tax advice
This is the service built for exactly the conversation this article started.
Explore Cryptocurrency tax adviceKaruna Malik
Founder, Forward Accounting · Registered Tax Agent · IPA Member
Karuna has 15+ years of experience helping Australian business owners, tradies, and investors legally maximise their tax positions and build lasting wealth.
